Note from Art: I plan on chronicling my experience in several posts over the next few weeks, with an exciting new men’s clothing/shopping service that I was introduced to called Trunk Club. I’m not sure if I’m more excited about the solution to my fashion challenges, or the fact that this is the best recent example that I’ve seen of a service that so perfectly solves a problem that it practically sells itself. (The authors of the book Tuned In describe this type of offering as a Resonator.)
I have no stake in the Trunk Club for Men and when I let the co-founder, Matthew Scott, know that I planned on posting about my experience with his service, he urged me to help them get better. I love his attitude! And I will.
I’m not sure guys are supposed to write posts about fashion. I’m expecting a call from my friend Chris, encouraging me to turn in my “man card” for writing on this topic. He did that the one and only time I was dumb enough to indicate that I might have caught a fleeting glimpse of Oprah’s show when author Marcus Buckingham was the guest.
We’ll Chris, my excuse is even better this time. I’m mixing fashion with business research. Take that!
OK, some background is in order here on the roots of my fashion challenges.
First, I am a child of the 70s, when to quote my kids looking at the old family pictures, “What were you people thinking?”
“Hey, what’s wrong with yellow and green plaid bell-bottoms paired with rust colored shirts?” I retort to these logo-covered and self-annointed fashion critics. I don’t have the heart to tell them that I look at these same pictures in horror that anyone ever thought those clothes were acceptable for public consumption.
For those too young to recall, the 70’s started out with post-hippie era styling and concluded with disco. Leisure suits were born somewhere in the middle of that “tasteful” decade.
Second, I transitioned at some point in my career from the standard blue suit, white shirt uniform that we wore at Panasonic to software-sloppy…the business casual that dominated the software industry for so many years.
Combine my 70’s experience with the blue suit to software casual experience, and I have a wardrobe that is just short of lousy with a sense of style that matches.
The Problem:
My professional world has transitioned from the daily corporate casual to super casual (home office) or on-stage as a speaker, seminar leader or MBA instructor. I need some great quality clothes for the “on” days, and thankfully, there are many of these days on the calendar in the coming months. It’s time for a wardrobe makeover.
A bit more background. is in order. I hate shopping. I hate shopping for clothing most of all. There are many bad things that could be done to me that would be less painful than shopping. The thought of it makes me recoil in horror. If my wife suggests a shopping trip that will take us even close to the Men’s department, my mind goes blank, my eyes glaze over and I immediately feel the need to take a long nap. Ask me to figure out any color and pattern combinations beyond white or off-white with dark and once again my mind goes blank.
I survived fashion hell for a number of years with a great retail clerk at the former Marshall Fields. Jan learned my tastes and did a pretty good job of helping me out during my once a year visit. Well, Fields is gone and so is Jan, replaced by crappy off the rack merchandise and unhelpful staff at the local Macy’s. My last fashion lifeline disappeared when Fields died.
Until now. Enter Trunk Club for Men. The service is positioned as an innovative new service for busy professional men and successful entrepreneurs. There is a membership component that gives it an air of personalization and exclusivity. If this works, it may rank as one of the great problem-solving discoveries of my adult life.
One to One meets Web 2.0:
Here’s the business in a nutshell. You start by visiting the website and completing an application. I was invited to join by the co-founder, but be aware that the process does involve completing a no-fee application that helps Trunk Club understand a bit more about you and your clothing tastes and needs. More about the application process in a future post.
Once you’ve been accepted as a member, you meet via webcam with a personal fashion consultant who interviews you to understand your requirements and your budget parameters. After your webcam interview, your fashion consultant shops for and ships your clothes.
Once you’ve received the shipment, you and your consultant reconvene on a webcam call to review the items. You decide what you will keep and return the rest, paying only for your final selections. That’s it. Oh, and your consultant will even direct you to a Trunk Club approved tailor in your area.
Let’s review:
- I never have to leave my house. The clothes come to me.
- I gain the best guidance of a fashion pro.
- I return what I don’t want and only pay for what I keep. There are no other fees or no minimum purchase amounts.
- The fashion consultant shops to my budget and seeks out the best quality and value that fits that budget.
- Unlike the visit to a retail store, your fashion consultant works with you over time to learn your likes and dislikes and to fill out your wardrobe with a plan in mind.
- If I need more of something, I send a note and things magically show up.
This rocks!
While I’m being a bit melodramatic in my description of my helplessness in the line of retail fire, I truly love this concept. I don’t know too many guys that care about shopping and those that do seem to operate with a search and destroy mentality. Go in, select and exit as quickly as possible. There’s no plan, just a short-term mission.
With Trunk Club for Men, my modus operandi hasn’t changed, but all of the pain is gone. I will spend minimal time thinking about the topic and leave the execution to a professional. No stores, no changing rooms, just a big box of things to try on in my home. Delegating to experts is something that I can handle. This seems right on so many levels!
My parameters to Darcy, my consultant, are to focus on developing a small selection of high quality items of classic styling for use in speaking and workshop engagements. Most of my work does not require a suit, so establishing a core grouping of jackets, shirts, slacks and ties is the top priority.
I can’t wait to see what Darcy sends me.
Stay tuned to see if this is as good as it sounds or too good to be true. I’m betting on the former.
Future Post: I’ll share more about the video interview and business process, as well as the results of Darcy’s shopping trip.
While my first inclination was to ask Art to surrender his “man card,” I must admit that I, too, love this concept.
While not firmly entrenched in the “70’s”, but rather in that middling 70’s/80’s era (yes, I had parachute pants, and a “Miami Vice” linen sport coat), my wardrobe today is a mix of designer-named polos, casual shirts, and way too much “logo wear” that requires (by the real person in charge) a one-for-one exchange when something new comes home after a golf tournament, or a terrific bargain at the local TJ Maxx.
Like you Art, the idea of approaching a 20-something person in a retail store and asking what they thought about a shirt/slack/sport coat combination is something I dread. Especially when that person is now dressed in clothing that harkens back to the 70’s era that you described at the top of your post.
If you’re like me, I find someone I trust, and take their opinion seriously. That is rare in retail where turnover is way too frequent. That’s why I love it when I can find a shirt/tie combo in a box at the local Kohl’s.
Now, there’s a new alternative — and I don’t have to face the crowds or the potential stick-pin in the foot that the last guy left on the floor after trying on a new dress shirt.
Thanks Art — the “card” is safe for now!
Chris
Art,
What a great pleasure in reading your post about your experience with The Trunk Club thus far.
Listen…when your students and your seminar participants greet you with chants of “you’re bringing sexy back” The Trunk Club is not liable for any groupie coverage! I’m just saying…
Art,
How totally cool. A service to transform all of us geeks into the image we want to portray without all the hassles. You know you have a resonator when folks refer a service willingly like you just did. Stay Tuned In!
Phil
So how do you make sure the clothes fit? What about alterations?
Thanks to all for comments and Chris, for letting me stay in the club!
Wally, you provide your measurements…and as indicated in the post, the consultant directs you to a Trunk Club approved tailor. Backup plan is Nordstrom’s. This area concerns me a bit… especially at start-up. Once sizing, styles, manufacturers are identified…the possibility of having to ship clothes back and forth goes down.
Stay tuned for my feedback on the entire experience.
An interesting idea. I look forward to hearing more about your experience. If it works out well for you, I might have to ask you for a referral. It may well beat working with a personal shopper from Nordstrom’s.
Take care and keep warm,
Andy
Hey Art, good on you for wanting to revamp the wardrobe! I’ve seen two classes worth of it and trust me, it ain’t that bad, but there are always opportunities for sustained improvement.
While this is a great concept, I would suggest that you take a leap and start to build your shopping experience by doing the trench work. Maybe by changing the context of why you’re shopping will help to make the process a little more focused, enjoyable, and rewarding. For example, piecing together a power suit for a specific upcoming event will help to narrow down exactly what you’re looking for based on need, thus narrowing the types and number of stores you’ll need to visit. Plus you have the vision of the image you’ll need to present for any given event in your mind…I imagine communicating this image, and the clothes necessary to complete the picture, to a consultant could be difficult. Also, beware that sizes may vary by designer.
You’ve done more difficult things in your lifetime than piecing together a solid outfit (yes, it’s entirely okay to use the word outfit. It’s when you tell friends that you’ve pieced together a rather charming little number that you lose the m-card). It will be important to remember that like any new venture, the first few attempts times will be the toughest. However you’ll eventually come to rely on a few stores that consistently have exactly what you’re looking for and will make future shopping trips much easier. You’ll invariably become a better shopper because you’ll stop resisting doing it. Your friends will start to ask you for fashion tips, which will undoubtedly impress your wife and her friends. Benefits abound.
My advice: take to Michigan ave (or the local mall) and make a day of it. Leave your expectations and any horrific memories from the past at the door. Don’t be afraid to approach young sales clerks and ask for advice…they’re going to make money off of you and are more than happy to help out. Keeping yourself practiced and familiar (whether it be shopping for your spring wardrobe or managing for performance) will make you more effective at it in the future. I think you just may surprise yourself.
Andrew, thanks for jumping in. Stay tuned.
Steve, thanks much for your personal cheerleading. If this doesn’t work out, I will definitely follow your retail coaching advice!
-Art